In which sentence are only two commas needed: the dog barked merrily from afar? - briefly
The sentence "The dog, barked merrily, from afar" contains three commas, which is incorrect. To correct it, only two commas are necessary. The correct punctuation would be: "The dog barked merrily, from afar."
The comma after "dog" is unnecessary because it incorrectly separates the subject from the verb. The comma after "merrily" is correct as it separates the adverb from the prepositional phrase. Therefore, the sentence should read: "The dog barked merrily, from afar."
The correct sentence with only two commas needed is: "The dog barked merrily, from afar, and briefly."
In which sentence are only two commas needed: the dog barked merrily from afar? - in detail
To determine the correct placement of commas in a sentence, it is essential to understand the grammatical structure and the purpose of punctuation. Commas are used to separate elements in a sentence to enhance clarity and readability. They can indicate pauses, separate items in a list, or set off introductory phrases. Let's analyze the sentence "the dog barked merrily from afar" and identify where commas are necessary.
First, consider the basic structure of the sentence. It consists of a subject ("the dog"), a verb ("barked"), and an adverbial phrase ("merrily from afar"). The adverbial phrase modifies the verb, describing how the dog barked. In this case, the phrase "merrily from afar" is a single unit that modifies the verb "barked." Therefore, no commas are needed within this phrase.
However, if we were to add more information or clauses to the sentence, commas might be necessary. For example, if we add an introductory phrase or a non-restrictive clause, commas would be required to set off these elements. Let's examine a few examples to illustrate this:
-
Introductory Phrase: "After a long day, the dog barked merrily from afar."
- Here, "After a long day" is an introductory phrase that sets the scene. A comma is needed after this phrase to separate it from the main clause.
-
Non-Restrictive Clause: "The dog, which was very excited, barked merrily from afar."
- In this sentence, "which was very excited" is a non-restrictive clause that provides additional information about the dog. Commas are needed to set off this clause from the rest of the sentence.
-
List of Actions: "The dog barked merrily from afar, wagged its tail, and ran towards its owner."
- In this example, the sentence lists multiple actions performed by the dog. Commas are used to separate the items in the list.
In the original sentence "the dog barked merrily from afar," no additional phrases or clauses are present that require commas. Therefore, no commas are needed in this simple sentence. However, if the sentence were to include an introductory phrase or a non-restrictive clause, two commas would be necessary to properly punctuate the sentence. For instance, "After a long day, the dog, which was very excited, barked merrily from afar." This sentence requires two commas: one after the introductory phrase and one to set off the non-restrictive clause.