What are they made of dead dogs? - briefly
They are typically made from dried fish or other animal products, not dead dogs.
What are they made of dead dogs? - in detail
The phrase "What are they made of dead dogs?" is a curious and somewhat macabre inquiry, often used in colloquial English to express disbelief or incredulity at a particular situation or statement. The idiom's origins are rooted in folklore and superstition, with various interpretations and regional variations.
Historically, the expression can be traced back to old European folk tales where it was believed that certain magical or supernatural objects were created using unconventional materials, including parts of animals such as dogs. In some stories, these objects held mystical properties capable of bringing good fortune or warding off evil spirits. The use of "dead dogs" in the phrase underscores the idea of something being made from an unexpected and unusual source, emphasizing the absurdity or implausibility of the situation being described.
In modern usage, the phrase is typically employed rhetorically to challenge the authenticity or credibility of a claim. For instance, if someone were to make an outlandish statement, another person might respond with "What are they made of dead dogs?" to express their skepticism and disbelief. The idiom serves as a humorous way to question the validity of information without directly accusing the speaker of lying.
Despite its somewhat gruesome imagery, the phrase is generally used in a lighthearted manner and does not carry any literal meaning or implication. It remains a colorful part of English idioms that reflects the rich tapestry of folklore and storytelling traditions that have shaped language over time.